Are we doing enough towards achieving the right to food?
The 2010 Kenyan Constitution has earned praise as one of the most progressive globally. Article 43 (1) (c) of the Constitution provides for the right of everyone to access adequate food of good quality at all times and in dignity through production or purchase.
This right is central to achieving the Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) number two on zero hunger by 2030, and in effect, contribute to achieving many of the SDGs. The global prominence of this right is underlined by the commitment of States to the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, and international conventions e.g. the International Covenant on Economic Social and Cultural Rights. In this final decade of action for the achievement of the SDGs, the key focus should be on the realization of the right to adequate food for all.
Adequate food, as envisioned in the right, should be achieved not only in quantity but also in quality. There is an unrivalled need to sustainably produce adequate quantities of food that is safe and nutritious for everyone at all times.
The food should essentially be able to adequately provide for the health and wellbeing of people. This is far from the truth in Kenya, where hunger and malnutrition are permanently resident in many households when farmers decry lack of markets for their produce, and markets and dumpsites are full of food wastes.
The question remains whether our policy and programmatic environment are geared towards the progressive realization of the right to adequate food as envisioned in the constitution and the realization of the zero hunger goal by 2030.
An alarming concern is the resilience of our food system that already has millions of people in Kenya going hungry in normal times. External shocks such as droughts, floods, locust invasion, pandemics such as COVID-19, among others adversely affect the food system exacerbating hunger and food insecurity in the population.
Shocking news of a mother cooking stones for her children in the wake of COVID-19 demonstrates the weaknesses of our food system, with many more facing hunger. COVID-19 pandemic has seriously worsened the food insecurity situation for Kenyans. This is demonstrated in the informal settlements as indicated by a recent study by the African Population and Health Research Center (APHRC) in Nairobi. The linkage between a working food system and the social wellbeing of a society cannot be overemphasized.
Hunger is coupled with concerns for food safety. There have been reports of increased use of inorganic pesticides and inorganic fertilizers and their effect on the ecosystem. Evidence points to degradation of soils and natural flora as well as reduced yield over time. There are also concerns about the effect of synthetic pesticides residues present in food on human health and wellbeing. This clearly indicates an unsustainable, degenerative and non-environmentally friendly production system.
The current food systems have resulted in massive environmental degradation, inequalities and social injustice. They contribute to about 80% deforestation, 29% of greenhouse gas emissions, withdraws about 70% fresh water and contributes to about 68% total biodiversity loss.
In her inaugural speech in 2014, Hilal Elver, the former UN’s Special Rapporteur on the Right to Food cautioned that “Modern agriculture, which began in the 1950s, is more resource-intensive, very fossil fuel dependent, using fertilizers, and based on massive production. Further, the dominating food systems see food as a commodity that is produced, processed, and marketed for profit to consumers. Many poor people, including many of the farmers who produce it cannot afford to feed themselves and thus are hungry. Turning a blind eye to this harsh reality is a disservice to present humanity, disobedience to our forefathers from whom we inherited the land and a curse to future generations, from whom we have borrowed the future. We need to recommonify food.
Hence there is need to transform our agriculture to boost nature-positive food production systems in order to achieve the 2030 zero hunger goal and actualize the right to adequate food as envisioned in our constitution. Agroecology is a promising approach to ensuring sustainable, resilient, human-centred food systems. It simultaneously applies ecological and social concepts in the food and agricultural systems to protect the ecosystem while taking care of the society. It promotes food sovereignty for small scale farmers, who feed the world, enhancing their agency, empowering them to make decisions regarding their food production.
Further, it promotes gender equity, protecting women’s rights, who play a major role in feeding the world. Enabling policy and legislative environment as well as political will are prerequisite to achieving this desirable transformation of the food production system. This, should not only be on paper but in practice.
It is time to action great policies, statutes, laws, dreams and aspirations that we have as a people, including Vision 2030, Big Four Agenda, National Food and Nutrition Security Policy, and all related regional and international conventions to which Kenya is party to. This can be done by realigning, reviewing amending, reprogramming and restructuring our policies, legislation, programs where necessary, and implement them accordingly.
The government must be more accountable for its actions towards this course, prioritize and make known to the public the progress the State is making towards the realization of the right to adequate food. The public, empowered to do so, must demand this accountability and a proper accountability system must be in place to facilitate this.
Article by: By Dr Elizabeth Kimani-Murage, David Osogo and Faith Kathoka